Travis Scott and Don Toliver are facing a copyright lawsuit over “What To Do?,” a track from the JACKBOYS compilation released in 2019. Israeli producer Niv Kalisky, professionally known as Early Yellow, alleges that a recorded sample he supplied was incorporated into the song without him receiving the master royalties he believes he is owed. The legal action also names Cactus Jack, Sony and several other collaborators involved with the recording.
A dispute over a seven-year-old JACKBOYS recording has brought Travis Scott and Don Toliver into a new copyright case. Producer Niv Kalisky, who works under the name Early Yellow, filed a lawsuit on November 17, 2026, arguing that his contribution to the group’s “What To Do?” should have generated a share of revenue from the finished sound recording.
The complaint focuses on a beat Kalisky says he provided to producers working on the song. According to his account, the recorded material was subsequently incorporated into the released version. He maintains that its use entitled him to recording royalties beyond the songwriting income he has already received, creating the central disagreement between the parties.
“What To Do?” appeared on the seven-track JACKBOYS project in December 2019. The compilation brought together artists associated with Scott’s Cactus Jack Records and debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard 200. The song itself reached No. 56 on the Billboard Hot 100 and No. 20 on the Hot Rap Songs chart, establishing a commercially significant release at the center of the present dispute.
Kalisky is not claiming to have been entirely excluded from the song’s official credits. He is already acknowledged as a songwriter and additional producer, and the lawsuit recognizes that he has received publishing income relating to the composition. His complaint concerns a different source of revenue: the rights associated with the actual sound recording containing his alleged sample.
That distinction is fundamental to the case. Publishing royalties relate to the underlying composition, including its musical and lyrical elements. Master royalties concern the commercial use of a particular recorded performance. These rights may involve different ownership arrangements, contractual obligations and revenue recipients, even when they relate to the same commercially released song.
For Kalisky, the existing songwriting credit does not settle the disagreement. He argues that supplying recorded material incorporated into the final track gives rise to additional rights that have not been properly addressed. Whether that argument establishes an enforceable entitlement depends on the relevant evidence, licensing arrangements and applicable copyright law.
The producer’s legal team claims it attempted to resolve the matter before taking the dispute to court. According to the complaint, requests for payment and accounting information were sent over several years to Cactus Jack and Epic Records, Sony’s label involved in distributing the project. Kalisky alleges those efforts failed to produce the royalties he sought.
His lawyers also claim that representatives of the defendants repeatedly indicated the matter would be resolved but did not ultimately provide a satisfactory outcome. These statements form part of the allegations set out in the complaint. They have not been established as findings of wrongdoing, and the defendants’ responses will be relevant to how the legal arguments develop.
The dispute reportedly extended to streaming platforms as well. Kalisky’s side says it submitted takedown requests concerning “What To Do?” to services including Spotify and Apple Music. According to the lawsuit, Sony responded by filing counter-notices that prevented the requested removal from proceeding in the manner the producer sought.
Those competing actions do not independently establish whether the recording infringed anyone’s copyright. A takedown request represents a claim concerning the use of protected material, while a counter-notice disputes the basis for removal. Determining the parties’ rights requires examination of the evidence rather than treating either administrative step as proof.
Alongside Scott and Toliver, the lawsuit names fellow JACKBOYS member Sheck Wes, Cactus Jack, Sony and producers connected to the track. Kalisky is pursuing copyright infringement claims and seeking compensation linked to revenue generated by the sound recording. The reported allegations concern rights and payments, rather than any dispute over the song’s original chart performance.
The revenue streams identified in the complaint include sales, digital streaming and synchronization licensing, which involves permission to use recorded music in other media. Kalisky wants a portion of what his legal team describes as substantial recording income. The amount, and whether any share is legally owed, remain matters to be determined.
Attorneys Justin M. Jacobson and Daniel Cruz Hernandez framed the lawsuit as an effort by a music producer to assert his rights. In comments made when the case was filed, they pointed to increasing awareness among producers about ownership and compensation. Representatives for the named defendants had not immediately responded to requests for comment when the initial report was published.
The timing of the lawsuit places an older recording back under scrutiny after the JACKBOYS project established itself as a successful part of Scott’s catalog. The original compilation helped introduce the collective’s sound to a wider audience, while the follow-up project JACKBOYS 2 arrived in July 2025 and also topped the Billboard 200.
Those commercial achievements provide context for why recording income has become the focus of the claim. However, chart positions and album sales cannot determine whether an individual producer is contractually entitled to master points. Any financial assessment would need to establish the rights associated with the particular sample and the terms under which it entered the final recording.
The case also illustrates how layered contemporary hip-hop production can be from a rights-management perspective. A track may contain contributions from multiple writers, producers and sound recordings, each potentially governed by different agreements. Crediting one contributor for songwriting does not necessarily answer every question about the licensing or ownership of recorded material.
For Travis Scott, Don Toliver and the other defendants, being named in the complaint does not amount to a determination of liability. The allegations concerning unauthorized use and unpaid royalties remain contested legal claims until the relevant proceedings establish otherwise. No final judicial finding on those allegations was reported in the initial coverage of the filing.
The question now is whether Kalisky can demonstrate an enforceable right to additional income from the recording of “What To Do?” His existing credits and publishing payments are acknowledged, but the claimed entitlement to master royalties is the unresolved issue. Its outcome will depend on the documentation, contractual arrangements and legal arguments presented in the case.



